
It seems I was slightly premature in posting my impressions of the Twilight Grass Moon as there were at least two endings that I hadn't seen until I finished the Ten Nights of Dream section. There isn't really a need to cover them, other then to say they add much needed closure on the whole story. If it hadn't been for the Internet I would have missed them entirely, so I'll just give you a clue about how to see them. Once the main game is finished and the day says "repeat again..." go back into "Twilight Grass Moon" and see if something has changed color. I will leave it at that.
The other major section of Kagetsu Tohya are ten short stories that are unlocked as you play the other half of the game. Seven of these stories are written by Nasu, the author of Tsukihime, and the other three are from "contributors". More on how I feel about that later.
I won't go into depth for these stories but just say how I feel about each of them briefly.
Good Luck, Ciel-senseiThis story isn't canon, or I guess you can say it happens on the fringe world of Tsukihime where all characters are self aware. It is much in the same vein as most of the Plus+Disc stories where the characters make fun of the world in which they all inhabit and talk about plot inconsistencies. Most of which readers wouldn't have been aware of if Nasu hadn't brought it up, but still it makes for a fun story. I liked the ones on Plus+Disc a lot more though.
A Story for the EveningThis was probably my favorite story of all ten. It is a direct sequel to Akiha's "True Ending" in Tsukihime. In Tsukihime her story was the most tragic of all the female heroine's but this story makes her "True Ending" the only one of the "True Endings" that actually ends happily.
Akiha returns to boarding school after Shiki's "death" and there is a weird mystery involving her, another student, and a sinister mailbox. I hate to make this comparison, but it sort of does the same thing that Final Fantasy X2 did, in that you think it is going down some route to bring back the hero from the original, and then it turns out to be something completely different. However, in this story it is handled much, much better than in FFX2.
Normally I'd be upset that such a good dramatic story got changed to have a non tragic ending in a sequel, but I will admit it always bugged me that Akiha, who I thought was a great character, was the only girl who got shafted on the endings, but her endings were tragedies, so this story rectifies that.
Crimson MoonBeing an Arcueid fan, I thought I would really like this story, but really I didn't. It is told from Roa's perspective when he met Arcueid and the Crimson Moon, but it is told in such a muddled and confusing way I'm still not really sure what happened in the story.
I have a feeling that I should have read the Plus Period Art book to get a better understanding, but as that is not translated this story is kind of lost on me.
Red Demon GodThis story was about Shiki's birth father. I'm not much on prequels where I know the protagonist is doomed, but as a short story it works really really well. Plus since Shiki is viewing the whole thing from some fragmented memory of his father, he gets to see that his father really loved and cared for him, and gave up his bloodthirsty ways to settle down. I'm glad the character of Shiki gets to see this because it gives him some much needed parental love since his adopted father was such a douche.
This was my second favorite story of the ten.
Nanako-chan SOSThis was a fun little divergent story with Shiki's pal Arihiko. This was the funniest story on the entire disc, and actually the funniest moments in the main story involved Nanako as well.
I feel like this whole thing could have been expanded into it's own visual novel, or a parody of one because the set up is very similar to a dating sim, except Arihiko and Nanako don't fit into the respective roles of a likable protagonist and a normal cute naive girl who just happens to drop in on the main character. You have to feel kind of bad for Arihiko as his best bud has dozens of beautiful women after him, and Arihiko gets stuck with the spirit of a gun that has hooves for hands.
Sadly the story doesn't really go anywhere, and just kind of ends without any closure. But I think that is part of the point.
ImogirisouThis is a parody of some old Visual Novel and subsequent movie. Having never read or seen either the parody went completely over my head. Still it has some funny moments. They break the forth wall a lot which as I've mentioned before, I can't stand.
Flower of ThanatosNot really much to say here except it was an excuse to include a hentai scene in these short stories. I like both Kohaku and Hisui, but if I only get one H scene with the girls from Tsukihime with Takashi Takeuchi much improved art style, I would have picked someone else.
Now on to the last three stories. Like I mentioned before, these were all written by people other then Nasu. I tried to give them a chance, knowing that, as Takeuchi did do art for them so may be considered canon. But really, you can tell they are written by people other then Nasu, and as such aren't any different from any random fanfic you can get through a Google search. It's really great he let other people play with his characters, but I just can't take them seriously.
The only one of the three I want to say anything about is
Dawn, and if I had to pick one to be considered canon, this would be it.
The reason is, unlike the other two stories, the author picked up from a loose end from Tsukihime, created new characters, and made a story within the Tsukihime universe that doesn't impact the main characters at all. Because of this it does much of what " Genshi Doumei" did in Plus+Disc. It helps to expand the world past the main characters and makes it feel like a living breathing universe. It also helped to win me over because the loose end it tied up was the same exact thing I bitched about myself in
Ciel's Ending review.
And that pretty much does it for Tsukihime's visual novels. It was a long road, but in the end I think I might just be more partial to Tsukihime more then Fate/Stay Night. Or at least I can say they are equal in my eyes, which I didn't think would ever happen. I can say I would be more willing to see more adventures with Tsukihime characters then with Fate/ characters.
Of course I still have all of Melty Blood to get through, and that is my next endeavor, but until the promised Tsukihime 2 is released (I won't hold my breath) the visual novels end here.